Cain kills his brother abel for some reason or other. Saying that cain and abel were real is like saying. The text seems to pose a problem as it makes reference to the wife of cain when so far in the text, only four human beings have been mentioned. In the day when god created man, he made him in the likeness of god. The narrative continues in genesis 4 with cain settling in the land of nod and having children with his wife. Rabbi menachem posner serves as staff editor at, the worlds largest jewish informational website. According to this reasoning, cain would have married his sisterone of abels twin sisters no less, according to the genesis rabbah. And for that matter, where did cains son enoch get his wife, given that cain was exiled. Hebrew readers should be able to make this connection easier. In a sunni islamic version, allah promises permits adam to marry one of the twin pairs with one of the pairs of qabil with the beautifullooking iqlimiya, while the twin pairs of his sister named abel and layudha are less attractive. Note warning to all christians who were taught a lie over the truth, you are about to be awakened. While it is true that the bible does not specifically say cain s wife was his sister, we know from scripture since adam and eve were the first and only human beings that their children would have no other choice than to marry each other in order to fulfill the divine command to be fruitful and multiply. Abel maintained that he should marry her because she was his triplet.
Adam, eve, cain and his brother abel whom he had killed. Were not told when cain married or many of the details of other marriages and children, but we can say for certain that cain s wife was either his sister or a close relative. Rabbi tovia singer explains who married adams sons duration. God did not forbid interfamily marriage until much later when there were enough people to make intermarriage unnecessary leviticus 18. Since they were both farmers, they were likely both fullgrown adults, possibly with families of their own. The bible does not say how old cain was when he killed abel genesis 4. Although the prosecutor during the scopes trial failed to answer this question, rabbi tovia singer addresses this conundrum live on air. Candice lucey contributing writer after the world was formed, god finished his work of creation by raising one man from the dust and one woman from the mans ribs. Cain did not marry his sister bible proves this over.
Or did he marry one of cains daughters, his own niece, although cain had been exiled by then. Adam and eve bore daughters in addition to their sons, one of whom became cains wife. Who picked and chose what books went in the bible, and did. Deals with this question from the king james version bible.
Notice, however, that cain did not marry before he settled in nod, and that when he did settle in nod, it was already populated. Cain, the firstborn, was a farmer, and his brother abel was a shepherd. Dont you think one of his sister would of went with himi dont think he did. This is usually because of societal taboos or fear of genetic defects. In the bible, all the people on earth at that time were directly descended from adam and eve. In addition, as the ancient rabbis attest, cain wouldve married one of his sisters. After all, abraham married his halfsister with no problems. Cain married a relative, just as, really, each person today marries one of his or her relatives.
After the world was formed, god finished his work of creation by raising one man from the dust and one woman from the mans ribs. The understanding in the sisterwife interpretation is basic and standard. Dna damage accumulates over time, but even 2000 years later. His word indicates that adam was the first man and eve the first woman. Intermarriages between brothers and sisters were permissible until god later gave the book of leviticus chapter 18 which condemned these relationships. Someone might have showed you that, but it wasnt god. In answer to this, conservative readers point to a later verse, gen 5. Mary joan winn leith first explores the traditional jewish and christian answers that contend that the wife of cain was another daughter of adam and eve. The only possible answer is that cains wife was his sister or niece or greatniece, etc. And cain took awan his sister to be his wife and she bare him enoch at the close of the fourth jubilee. But later during the patriarchal age, as an increasing number of men and women cousins became available, cousins with an increasing number of removals, then what i think is our. Therefore, she had to be his sister or possibly niece. Skeptics of the bible have used cains wife time and again to discredit the book of genesis as a true historical record. Changed with law it was when god gave the people the law of moses that he established laws forbidding a man from marrying a sister or niece.
Since adam and eve were the first and only human beings, their children would have no other choice than to intermarry. After god created adam and eve, they had sons and daughters gen 5. This answer may sound revolting for those of us who grew up in societies that have attached a stigma to such an idea, but if we start from scripture, the answer is clear. When did god no longer allow marriage between close relatives. She actually was his niece daughter of his halfbrother haran and he stretched the truth when he called her his sister. So enoch, no doubt, also married his own sister, the daughter of cain and his unnamed wife. Skeptics have pointed out that the only viable solution to the problem of cain s wife cain marrying his sister suffers from theological problems, since close relations were not allowed to marry according to jewish law. Cain and his wifes relationship was a marriage between brother and sister at the first generation level of humans, and, therefore, it was without any genetic danger. May 23, 2014 cain did not marry his sister bible proves this over and over. Well this verse pretty much sums up the reality of where cain as well as his brother seth got his wife.
The third generations of humans had no need for this loophole, because marriage between first cousins is not considered incest according to torah law. Since men and women lived to be hundreds of years old in the primeval world, populations grew rapidly, and cain had plenty of time to marry a sister or possibly a niece, move to nod, and build a city for his own descendants and others. Cain couldnt have married one of his daughters but he could have married a sister or a niece. Cain did not marry his sister bible proves this over and over.
If adam and eve were the first people, and cain their first child, whom did he marry. Depending on how much time there was between cain being married, he either married a distant sister, or if enough time transpired, he could have married his own niece. Jan 19, 2009 dont you think one of his sister would of went with himi dont think he did. Jul, 2014 we know that adam and eve had other sons and daughters in addition to abel, cain, and seth gen. As adam and eve were the first human pair on earth, and by natural generation had three sons who are namedcain, abel, sethand there is no mention of any. One of the most oftenasked questions about the bible is that of cains wife. Nov 16, 2018 cain and his wifes relationship was a marriage between brother and sister at the first generation level of humans, and, therefore, it was without any genetic danger.
Jun 22, 2005 quotemamageekif adam and eve are the parents of all humankind, did cain marry his sister. Let me explain by answering this question with another question. He has uncovered the nakedness of his sister, he shall bear his guilt. How did god intend for people to be fruitful and multiple without sinning. Cain most likely married his sister cain likely married a sister or a niece. It is rather unfortunate that churches and religious leaders seem to have severely dropped the ball when it comes to this very common question. Cain did not marry his sister bible proves this over and. He has been writing, researching, and editing for since.
If cain married his sister, he did not commit incest because incest did not become a crime until thousands of years later. Cain did not marry his sister, because like the story of adam and eve, the story of cain and abel is dr. God had commanded to be fruitful and multiply, he had not yet given a command against marrying a sister that didnt happen until moses time, and the genetic makeup of man was clearly different at this time due to the old ages of the patriarchs and the ability to procreate in close relations without severe birth defects. And in the first year of the first week of the fifth jubilee, 197 a. That cain married his sister or a later female descendant of adam through the marriage of any of adams sons or daughters is viewed by some societies today as unthinkable. For more on this issue, including why intermarriage among adam and eves children in the first generation is morally acceptable, please see our previous response. Did cain marry his sister or did he searchout and find a woman from elsewhere. Travis shaffer, pastor of greenvale baptist church in gray station tn. Nowhere does genesis say that they bore only cain and abel before later creating seth. We know that adam and eve were the first people, so who did cain and abel marry in order to multiply the human race. Cain claimed the right to this sister because he was the firstborn. So cain knew his wife in the land of nod and they had a.
He could have married his sister or his niece, or his grandniece, or his greatgreatgreatgreatgreatgreatgrandniece i think you get the idea. Cain then either takes one of his sisters in the version featuring aqlima, abel also has a twin sister and marries her after his flight from home, or. And though we now follow guidelines of marriage by way of levitical law, we are still, all from the same family. After all, abraham married his half sister with no problems.
Even if people choose to believe we came from primordial soup, when we began to marry we married a relative. Saying that cain and abel were real is like saying that spot and puff and dick and jane in the old 1950s and 1960s grade school readers were real. The simple answer is that cain married his sister or another close relation, like a niece. They had no congenital defects to pass on to their offspring. Cains wife all the women of the bible bible gateway. The short answer is that the brothers had to marry their sisters.
Because she would see her brother able in the face a cain everyday of her life. Cain knew his wife, and she conceived and bore enoch. Sep, 2007 thus, cains wife is a descendant of adamman. Where did cain get his wife if there were only 3 people on. Some might replay that such would be wrong, because it would be incest. Cain was married to either his sister or his niece. No woman in scripture has caused as much confusion as cains wife. The most commonly held belief among christians is that cains wife was simply one of his sisters.
Consequently, although this is not stated, the only logical conclusion is that cain married his sister and they had children. The lord made only two people, so the only people available for adam and eves sons to marry were their own sisters. The couples first three children were cain, abel and seth, after he begot seth, were eight hundred years. Brothersister marriage is inescapable, unless we resort to more such deus ex machina explanations of special creations of more women. Since they were physically almost perfect, they would have no need to worry about genetic deformities.
Since the bible normally does not record the birth of a daughter, we wouldnt have record of these births. People have often asked, where did cain get his wife. Consequently, although this is not stated, the only logical conclusion is that cain married his sister and they had children together. Some of these had apparently moved away and settled east of eden, in nod, where cain and his wife moved to. When cain tells god, whoever finds me will kill me genesis 4. In the biblical book of genesis, cain and abel are the first two sons of adam and eve. The brothers made sacrifices to god, each of his own produce, but god favored abels sacrifice instead of cain s. When did god no longer allow marriage between close.
For more on this issue, including why intermarriage among adam and eves children in the first generation is. That r some sign of incomplete bible,hadit says cain marry his sister,paul did not witness d lifetime of adam so d bible didnt reveal it but d superior god know everytin and has been revealed in d islamic scripture 1 woman raised from the dead after 12 days. Brothersister marriage is inescapable, unless we resort to more such deus ex machina explanations of special creations of. The earliest inhabitants of earth had no other choice than to marry their brothers and sisters in order to fulfill the divine command, be fruitful and multiply acts 17. And cain went out from the presence of the lord, and dwelt in the land of nod, on the east of eden. Can he make two mountains without making a valley in between. There are numerous examples of incest in the bible. The book of genesis tells us that adam and eve had two sons, cain and abel. According to the bible, we are all descendants of adam and eve and the only ones who can benefit from the salvation provided by god romans 5. The debate over who became the wife of cain and abel has gone on for centuries.
In order for their children to marry and reproduce, it was necessary for brothers to marry their sisters. And he then founded a city, and named the city after his son enoch. The bible says that after he killed his brother abel, cain married a wife. While the bible does not give a complete account of the order or names of adam and eves children, it does say that he adam had other sons and daughters genesis 5. Marriage to a sister in the early stage of the human race was not considered wrong or unnatural. In the ancient times, it was considered acceptable to marry a sister as in egypt or half sister in many other places so he was able to use an excuse that his. The scriptures are clear, eve was the mother of both cain and cain s wife, his sister.
223 1433 740 130 966 462 879 39 1303 1503 1454 1588 1243 708 79 1422 26 1351 28 720 1173 944 529 212 1139 491 782 1312 1119 1476 424 715 751 1371 652 1366 7 1494 1289 58 1261