Last year at the au summit, the current president of kenya urged for the immediate establishment of the court. Pdf the role of the east african court of justice in the. The influence of the child justice act 75 of 2008 on the. Agenda 2063 is the blueprint and master plan for transforming africa into the global powerhouse of the future. Oct 28, 2016 as a result, the au in 2008 adopted a protocol on the establishment of african court of justice and human rights acjhr. The pros and cons of the criminal jurisdiction of the. Jurisdiction and compliance in recent decisions of the. The treaty creating the african court of justice and human and peoples rights, if and when it comes into force, contains innovative elements that have potentially significant implications for current substantive and procedural approaches to regional and international dispute settlements. South african justice system is also on trial with the world watching, justice must be seen to be done in the killings of reeva steenkamp and anene booysen. Protocol on amendments to the protocol on the statute of the. Th ese reports could have led to the girl being identifi ed, and were thus technically in breach of the act. Justice centre in port elizabeth, which illustrate how restorative justice is a better option to retributivepunitive justice.
The court would be easily accessible for victims and all participants in the international criminal justice. Protocol on amendments to the protocol on the statute of. Protocol on amendments to the protocol on the statute of the african court of justice and human r ights malabo protocol reconceptualizes the idea of transitional justice mechanisms as varying approaches meant solely to. Protocol of the court of justice of the african union, adopted on 11 july 2003 in maputo, mozambique, are hereby replaced by the present protocol and statute annexed as its integral part hereto, subject to the provisions of article 5, 7 and 9 of this protocol. Dp201 the icc, africa and the au european centre for.
All that said, the merged african court has yet to come into being. Understanding the east african court of justice the hard road to independent institutions and human rights jurisdiction by philomena apiko this background paper is part of a series on the political economy dynamics of regional organisations pedro. African court of justice and human rights africlaw. Adding a third mandate to the african court will further drain away resources needed to. Pdf the international court of justice and borderconflict. The court was established by virtue of article 1 of the protocol. The court of justice of the european union is the institution of the european union which encompasses the whole judiciary. The south african legal system is a blend of british common law, dutchroman law and customary law, reflective of its colonial history. The east african community eac has demonstrated some effectiveness in promoting regional cooperation in economic relations. Opening the international court of justice to third states.
It was founded in 2004 by a merger of the african court on human and peoples rights and the court of justice of the african union. Peoples rights and the african court of justice could already dilute the work of the former. This is in light of the objectives of the dialogue of fostering connectivity between national, regional and continental judicial mechanisms. It is the strategic framework for delivering on africas goal for inclusive and sustainable development and is a concrete manifestation of the panafrican drive for unity, selfdetermination, freedom, progress and collective prosperity pursued under pan. As a result, the au in 2008 adopted a protocol on the establishment of african court of justice and human rights acjhr. The pros and cons of the criminal jurisdiction of the proposed african court of justice and human rights charle sello mabunda1 the problem of enforcement of human rights has always been a challenge in africa. Amidst all the political turmoil, and in spite of the huge political pressure, however, the court kept its back straight and concluded in two subsequent judgments, namely prof. Oct 15, 2014 possi, ally, the east african court of justice. The african court on human and peoples rights the court is a continental court established by african countries to ensure the protection of human and peoples rights in africa. The protocol is being circulated and so far 11 countries have signed the document. However, the au sought to join them in order to deal with human rights abuses and political disputes before a single court. Statute of the court of justice of the european union curia.
The international court of justice and borderconflict resolution in africa. Court will replace the existing protocols establishing, on the one hand, the african court of justice, and on the other hand, the african court on human and peoples rights. The court must in addition possess the requisite capacity to process the array of legal issues in which it has jurisdiction and its orders must be implemented and enforced for the court to have the desired impact. When the case was reported in the south african criminal law reports, it was referenced. Further, prosecutors are instructed that there is no reason to request a separation of trials even though the child was dealt with separately during the preliminary enquiry. The african court on human and peoples rights must start its work. Practical guide the african court on human and s t. The merged african court of justice and human rights acj. One striking example is the international court of justice. The article makes recommendations on how the african court of justice and human rights can be improved to enhance the advancements of human rights in africa. The court has, however, never come into existence because the african union has decided that it should be merged with the african court on human and peoples rights to form a new court. For the purposes of a particular case, the court may also include upon the bench one or more persons chosen under article 31 of the statute to sit as judges ad.
Implications of the au decision to give the african court. The legitimacy of the east african court of justice eacj to adjudicate human rights cases has been a debatable aspect ever since the courts inception. The bakassi peninsula conflict article pdf available in mediterranean quarterly 183 july 2007 with 4,816 reads. Jessup, intervention in the international court, ajil 75 1981. Some even revealed details of her residential address. Low court hours less than 3h30 pd per rc low number of finalised cases per court 7pm per rc in 0607 now 0708 decreased to 6pm per rc capacity number of courts hcrcdc judges and magistrates numbers of prosecutors move towards 2 per court, but 24% in 0607 now 070817% vacancies vs unequal. The east african community eac treaty established the east african court of justice in 1999. The international criminal court, africa and the african union. It is inevitable that other international tribunals will apply the law. How traditional justice in nigeria is changing british council. The african court of justice and human rights is meant to.
The article then concludes that africa might not be ready for this extension of jurisdiction of the merged court to try international crimes as this stance will take away the gains already. The african court and the african commission 32 the positioning of the court within the african regional judicial. East african court of justice does not have jurisdiction. The african court of justice and human rights acjhr is an international and regional court in africa. Chinkin, third parties in international law, 1993, 153. Its malcontents criticize the court as an ineffective player in achieving international peace and security. The role of the east african court of justice in the promotion, protection and enforcement of human rights in uganda submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the degree llm human rights and democratisation in africa. This trend is manifested in england, particularly in the court of appeal, by the recent development of a duty to act fairly in administrative law. The court s major responsibility is to ensure the adherence to law in the interpretation and application of and compliance with the eac treaty.
It is the primary judicial agency of the african union the court is based in the city of arusha, tanzania, as is the international criminal tribunal for. Dr bob arnot, national manager of the j4a programme, explains how it works, and what kind of interventions can strengthen traditional rulers authority while improving access to justice for the population there are many types of traditional rulers in nigeria. The african court on human and peoples rights towards the african court of justice and human rights practical guide april 2010 the afric a n c our t on h um a a nd po p les r igh t s towards the african court of justice and human rights pr a c t ic a l g uide fidh takes action for the protection of victims of human rights violations. The east african court of justice the court, is one of the organs of the east african community established under article 9 of the treaty for the establishment of the east african community. Adding a third mandate to the african court will further drain away resources needed to shore up the. It is the strategic framework for delivering on africas goal for inclusive and sustainable development and is a concrete manifestation of the panafrican drive for unity, selfdetermination, freedom, progress and collective prosperity pursued under panafricanism and african. Protocol of the court of justice of the african union. It complements and reinforces the functions of the african commission on human and peoples rights. Most courts follow south african common law, but will apply customary law when it is appropriate to do so. The territorial jurisdiction then covered aden, kenya, seychelles, somalia, tanganyika, uganda and zanzibar.
Practical guide the african court on human and s t peoples. The present article analyzes the african court of justice and human rights, the proposed main judicial organ of the african union. Articles 6d and 72 of the east african community eac treaty mention human rights, which ordinarily the eacj is mandated to interpret. Treatment of juvenile offenders and their reintegration into society treatment of juvenile offenders and their reintegration into society index content page chapter 1. Many have sought a structural solution to this problem in the form of an african court on human and. Dr bob arnot, national manager of the j4a programme, explains how it works, and what kind of interventions can strengthen traditional rulers authority while improving access to justice for the population. Caribbean court of justice winston anderson jamaica extraordinary chambers in the courts of cambodia rowan downing qc australia european court of human rights erik mose norway 2015 biij program committee david thor bjorgvinsson former judge, iceland international court of justice.
The east african court of justice eacj is one of the organs established under article 9 of the east african community treaty1. East african court of justice does not have jurisdiction to. Since its adoption in 1998, only 27 of the 54 member states of the african union au have ratified the protocol, south africa being one of them. Colloquium on the african court on human and peoples. In a wellfunctioning, independent, and efficient justice system, decisions are taken within a reasonable time and are predictably and effectively enforced, and individual rights, including property rights, are adequately protected. The court shall be composed of a body of inde pendent judges, elected regardless of their nation ality from among persons of high moral character, who. It is the primary judicial agency of the african union. This was presented to the executive council of the au at the summit in abuja, nigeria, january 2005. This panel drafted a protocol entitled, draft protocol on the integration of the african court on human and peoples rights and the court of justice of the au. Jurisdiction article 23 of the treaty states that the purpose of the court is to ensure the adherence to law in the interpretation.
Mending fences asfs project promoting the rome statute system and enhancing the effectiveness of the icc is supported by the macarthur foundation and the european commission. Paragraph p states that a court can sit simultaneously as an ordinary court and a child justice court when trying an adult and child coaccused. The proposed overall theme of the dialogue is connecting national and international justice. The court was inaugurated in november 2001 and heard its first case in 2005. The court has, however, never come into existence because the african union has decided that it should be merged with the african. It contrasts juvenile justice professionals shift from a punitiveretributive approach towards a restorative juvenile justice system.
An effective and efficient justice system is essential for sustained economic growth. The old legal adage is justice delayed is justice denied. After several amendments, the protocol on the statute of the african court of justice and human rights. Before taking up his duties each judge shall, before the court of justice sitting in open court, take an oath to perform his duties. Traditional justice outside the formal system in nigeria brings both advantages and problems. The international court of justice hereinafter, the icj or the court is the principal judicial organ of the united nations. The court of justice of the african union was originally intended to be the principal judicial organ of the african union protocol of the court of justice of the african union, article 2. The african justice cascade and the malabo protocol. Statement regarding immunity for sitting officials before the expanded african court of justice and human rights.
Nov, 2014 statement regarding immunity for sitting officials before the expanded african court of justice and human rights. Reforming south africas criminal justice system by mark shaw, project leader and senior researcher, crime and policing policy project, institute for defence policy occasional paper no 8 august 1996 introduction south africas system of criminal justice is in a crisis. In that speech president schwebel had stated, in particular. Historically, the court can trace its roots to the court of appeal for eastern africa which was established in 1909. Jun 04, 2014 the third part of this article focuses on the draft merged court and its amendments and whether the protocol will be adopted ad ratified. To date, of the 15 ratifications required before the protocol can enter into force, only two have been.
Advisory opinions of the international court of justice on questions. In june 2014, the african union adopted a protocol at its 23 rd ordinary session. Underlying this decision was the concern at the growing number of au institutions, which the au could not. The mission of the court is to enhance the protective mandate of the african commission on human and peoples rights by strengthening the human rights protection system in africa and ensuring respect for and compliance with the african charter on human and peoples rights, as well as other international human rights instruments, through. President of the african court, justice augustino ramadhani, speaking at the colloquium on the african court on human and peoples rights held by the law society of south africa. The oath of office shall be administered by the chairperson of the assembly or his or her duly authorized representative. How traditional justice in nigeria is changing british. Access to justice the establishment of a criminal jurisdiction body within the african continent would bring easy access to justice in africa. East african court of justice eac headquarters, 1st floor, africa mashariki road, eac close, p.
Juma, the anatomy of the african court of justice and human rights 269 ter on human and peoples rights7 in general during this transition. Towards effective protection of human rights in the east african community october 14, 20. Max planck yearbook of united nations law, volume 17, 20, p. Of these losses and silences, the linkages between the new court and the african commission on human and peoples rights,8 the limited direct access of individuals and nongovernmental organizations ngos be. Fairness and natural justice in english and south african law. The african court of justice 189 zaorv 66 2006 2005 it had been signed by 36 member states but ratified by only eight. African court of justice and human rights wikipedia.
354 1245 277 1307 760 1158 588 806 267 1253 367 1525 192 1114 809 255 1539 215 1291 1395 390 975 1005 1176 1107 844 1568 677 335 600 1394 175 1271 349 417 1142 206 326 527 1206 267 1051